I agree ... but in the words made famous by Ronald Reagan "doveriai, no proveriai". On more than one occasion I have enforced a right to audit supplier invoices. The first time I did it was when I was working for CN Railways, the supplier was (and is) a Canadian subsidiary of a global "MRO" parts supplier.
The relationship was worth about C$12 million a year, mostly driven through a huge number of small dollar transactions. Work to integrate the supplier into our EDI system led the team to wonder about the quality of the data feed from the invoices (a polite way of saying that their pricing seemed wacked). We had the right to audit, and on 24 hours notice put a couple of internal auditors into the supplier's offices. We agreed to sample about 1000 invoices and share the results with the supplier. We found that roughly 50% of the invoices had pricing errors which pointed to our concern about the quality of their data system, when we also observed that about 83% of the errors were in the supplier's favour it suggested that we might also have an ethical concern about their behaviour. The difference between contracted prices and invoiced prices was roughly $1M (8% of the C$12 million in sales). For a railway that only made $75M in profit that year, it was pretty significant.
The very talented guys over at "The Buying Triangle" are working on this type of problem (and others). Here's how they describe a portion of their solution:
Analyzing costs of goods and services—the third node on The Buying Triangle—can
be difficult to validate without effective price discovery. After contracts are
negotiated, the work of determining whether savings are real or theoretical
still lies ahead. This is often complicated by factors such as:
* the best pricing may be for items rarely used much of what you buy may actually be off-contract
* you can't validate contract compliance because you can't produce a detailed breakdown of historical purchases
I suspect that some of the buyers who experienced "elevated pricing" in Europe got the "verify" bit right. What are you doing to verify your supplier contracts?
Cheers,
David Rotor
Elevator lobby group. Heh.
ReplyDeleteWish I had thought of that one. Heh indeed.
ReplyDelete