What's the number?

I've negotiated a fair number of contracts over the years. Most of the time its a simple exercise of determining the how much will one pay for a good or service. But when the transaction is extended in time or over a number of payments even the simplest transaction can become difficult to conclude. I've found that one of the biggest issues is a disconnect between what is emotionally fair, and what is numerically reasonable.

Let's take a car purchase. A dealer has it listed at $38,789 after some negotiation you settle on a price of $35,600. The dealer then asks if you would like to finance the car over 6 years, and offers to do so at $702/month. Is that a good deal? In order to decide you need to be able to calculate some numbers, and have some external information. One piece of information you need is "what interest rate would someone charge me to borrow $35,600 and repay the loan over six years?"

In this case, the answer depends on whether you can get someone else to write this loan for less than 12.3%. All in all, these are not difficult calculations (and any number of web-sites, calculators, or spreadsheets will perform them for you).

However ... when you are negotiating procurement or outsourcing contracts don't assume all the parties at the table will be able to perform these calculations - especially "right there at the table" and that even if they can, that they will think the result is reasonable.

I'm often surprised at how frequently clients (and sales staffs) get tied up on this issue when services are paid on a deferred basis. You will often see sales staff asking for outrageously high margins just as often as you'll find a client wondering why they can't pay, for example, $1M in 10 years for $1M in services today.

And just when you think everyone is on the same page and being all reasonable, then we need to consider deal and partner specific risk ...

Cheers,

David Rotor

A quick hello and and some fast procurement news

I've been off working on a confidential client project so I have not been able to post anything recently. But I thought some of you might find this juxtaposition of two of my favourite topics interesting.

The rising cost of carbonfibre

"The current worldwide shortage of carbonfibre is going to make it more difficult and more expensive to build racing cars, until supply catches up with demand."

Click on the link for the full story from www.grandprix.com